Alumina Continuous Fiber vs. Other Continuous Fibers: A Technical Comparison
When selecting advanced insulation or reinforcement fibers for high-performance applications, engineers must evaluate materials across several key metrics: temperature resistance, mechanical strength, chemical stability, and cost-effectiveness. This article presents a comparative overview of alumina continuous fiber—such as Vulcan Shield Global’s B-70, F-72, C-85, and M-99 grades—against other leading continuous fibers: silicon carbide (SiC) fiber, carbon fiber, and fiberglass (E-glass/S-glass).
Thermal Capability & Stability
Alumina Continuous Fiber
Alumina continuous fibers provide exceptional thermal performance, with stable operation in environments up to 1350°C. They retain structural integrity at high temperatures and exhibit minimal thermal shrinkage, making them ideal for extreme aerospace, metallurgical, and industrial insulation use.
Silicon Carbide Fiber (SiC)
Silicon carbide continuous fibers also tolerate temperatures up to 1600°C and are often used in high-stress structural composites. However, they are prone to oxidation unless coated and have higher thermal conductivity, which can be a disadvantage in insulating applications.
Carbon Fiber
Carbon fiber maintains mechanical performance at elevated temperatures but begins to oxidize rapidly above 400–600°C in air, limiting its use in unprotected high-temperature environments. While excellent in inert or vacuum environments, it requires protective coatings for insulation roles.
Fiberglass (E-glass/S-glass)
Fiberglass continuous fibers are widely used due to their low cost, but thermal performance is limited to ~500–800°C. Above these temperatures, fiberglass begins to soften and lose strength, making it unsuitable for applications involving sustained high heat.
Mechanical Properties & Structural Durability and Modulus
Alumina Continuous Fiber
VSG’s alumina fibers exhibit high tensile strength (up to ~2.4 GPa) and modulus, ensuring long-term structural integrity under mechanical and thermal stress. They maintain mechanical performance even at elevated temperatures and after prolonged thermal cycling.
Silicon Carbide Fiber (SiC)
SiC continuous fibers offer excellent strength and stiffness, comparable or superior to alumina fibers, but their oxidation sensitivity can lead to embrittlement unless advanced protective coatings are applied.
Carbon Fiber
Carbon fiber has an outstanding strength-to-weight ratio, often exceeding 3–4 GPa tensile strength with high modulus. However, in oxidative environments or under prolonged thermal cycling, degradation occurs unless specific protection is applied.
Fiberglass
Fiberglass has relatively moderate tensile strength compared to ceramic or carbon fibers. It performs adequately at moderate temperatures but lacks the resilience and thermal durability of alumina fibers.
Chemical Stability & Oxidation Resistance
Alumina Continuous Fiber
Alumina continuous fiber is chemically inert and retains performance in acidic, alkaline, oxidizing, corrosive, and humid conditions up to 1350°C. These properties make them ideal for harsh processing environments such as furnaces, reactors, and aerospace heat shields. Not as ideal in reductive atmospheres like hydrogen (H2).
Silicon Carbide Fiber (SiC)
SiC continuous fibers are chemically stable but sensitive to high-temperature oxidation without a protective environment. Advanced coatings can mitigate this, but they add complexity and cost to the system.
Carbon Fiber
Carbon fibers degrade rapidly in oxidizing environments above ~400°C. Despite their superior mechanical properties in inert conditions, their poor oxidation resistance limits use without protective matrix systems.
Fiberglass
Glass fibers are susceptible to corrosion by acids, alkalis, and moisture, particularly at elevated temperatures. Their structural integrity declines significantly when exposed to aggressive environments
Cost & Lifecycle Considerations
Alumina Continuous Fiber
While alumina fibers are more expensive than traditional fibers, they offer outstanding durability, reduced replacement frequency, and energy efficiency—leading to superior total cost of ownership (TCO) in demanding environments for certain applications.
Silicon Carbide Fiber (SiC)
SiC continuous fibers are among the most expensive high-performance fibers, often justified in aerospace and defense applications requiring extreme strength and stiffness. Added protective coating requirements may increase lifecycle costs.
Carbon Fiber
Carbon fiber has a favorable cost-performance ratio in structural composites but lacks durability in oxidizing high-temperature conditions. Frequent replacements or complex processing can offset initial cost benefits.
Fiberglass
Fiberglass is inexpensive and widely available but degrades quickly in extreme heat or chemical environments. It’s suited for low to moderate thermal demands but not for high-performance insulation or reinforcement roles. The diameter of fiberglass is also relatively low which poses a significant health risk
Conclusion: Why Alumina Continuous Fiber Excels
When durability, thermal endurance, and chemical resilience are mission-critical, alumina continuous fibers rise above the competition. They deliver unmatched structural integrity at high temperatures, thrive in aggressive environments that are corrosive and acidic and outperform traditional options in long-term reliability. Whether you’re engineering aerospace insulation, designing advanced thermal barriers, or lining industrial furnaces, alumina fiber offers a premium solution that balances performance with lifecycle value.
Contact Us
Ready to explore how alumina continuous fibers can elevate your thermal and structural performance? Our team of materials specialists is here to help.
Email: sales@vulcanshield.com
Phone: (65)6513 8802, (65)8030 8729
Website: www.vulcanshield.com
Head Office: 10 Marina Boulevard, #13-01, Marina Bay Financial Centre, Tower 2, Singapore 018983
Whether you’re developing aerospace components, optimizing industrial insulation, or comparing fiber solutions, we’re here to provide expert guidance, samples, and technical support.
Contact us to find out more about how we can help fulfil your needs.